Specialist, top-rated family law advice, representation and mediation in the heart of the city of Cambridge.

Contact us for an initial chat about how we can help you.

Contact

Contact

01223 443331

Published On: 23 April 2024

High Court orders American father to make a lump sum child support payment

The High Court has made an unusual ‘capitalisation’ order against a wealthy but uncooperative father, requiring him to make a significant lump sum payment to the mother of his child.

The case centred on the estranged parents of a three-year-old girl referred to in the judgement as ‘Zoe’. Zoe suffers from a genetic illness and has special needs. The father lives in the United States, while the mother lives with Zoe in London.

In March 2023, Mr Justice Cobb ruled on the father’s child support obligations, declaring that these should include close to £150,000 per annum, along with over £90,000 for a nanny and private nursery fees, in order to help fund therapy and treatments for the girl.

Not long afterwards, the father met his daughter for the very first time, when the mother took her to meet him in his home state. They stayed for two weeks. In the Family Division of the High Court, Mr Justice Cobb explained:

“The mother reports that the father and Zoe enjoyed seeing each other, and in that sense the visit was a success. However, the mother also reports that during the visit the father informed her that he intended not to honour the court-ordered financial obligations which I had explained in my … judgment.”

The Judge continued:

“The mother’s … is that the father told her that she would “not see a penny” of the award which I had made, and that he had been “arranging and managing his finances for years to limit/restrict [the mother’s] ability to enforce”. He led the mother to understand that he had a plan to place her under such financial pressure in the UK that she would move to the USA, where he would make enhanced financial provision for her and Zoe.”

A series of drawn-out negotiations followed, during which the father insisted he was “heavily invested in ensuring that the needs of his daughter are met”. In spite of this, he paid only £7,200 per month in child support, as result of which the mother had to leave her flat and also suspend therapy sessions for Zoe.

Nevertheless, the parents remained in contact with each other, and Zoe and her father spoke to each other on Zoom. The mother denied threatening to prevent further contact if he did not comply with Judge Cobb’s order.

Subsequently, the mother applied, without notice to the father, for a worldwide freezing order to be placed on assets held by the father of more than £8 million, and then for ‘capitalisation’ of the father’s support obligations – i.e. the immediate payment of a lump sum, instead of a series of monthly “periodical” payments. The father refused to cooperate with these proceedings as well.

Mr Justice Cobb granted both the mother’s applications, explaining:

“In my judgment, this is indeed one of those “very rare” cases in which it would be appropriate to order capitalised periodical payments and other support payments (school and nanny). I say so for a number of reasons:

i) The father has, over a protracted period, shown himself unwilling to recognise the authority of this court, and a wilful failure to submit to its orders;

ii) The father is resident abroad, and therefore out of reach of other enforcement strategies;

iii) The registration and enforcement process is likely to be a difficult and uncertain process in the USA. The advice from the mother’s US attorneys is that it would be helpful if the claim for enforcement could be made once, and once only, with a claim for a single order for a capital lump sum (clearly defined as child support); I am advised that this will assist the US courts in making an order and will assist the enforcement authorities in recovering the monies…”

He concluded:

“…Zoe has unusual and very particular health needs … I sense that the father has an overestimated expectation that Zoe’s multiple medical needs can all be met in a timely and/or satisfactory way on the National Health Service in England, thus relieving him of the obligation to fund private health care. He has a similar view of Zoe’s capacity to access, and benefit from, state education without significant support. These views are not only unrealistic, but they fail to meet the mother’s well-made case for Zoe to receive intense and bespoke treatments in order to maximise her potential.”

Kathryn Evans, one of the partners at Cambridge Family Law Practice, said:

“Capitalisation is a measure rarely resorted to by the family courts in child support cases, as it can place a considerable burden on the paying parent that may not always be fair. But there are circumstances when it is an appropriate measure and this case clearly illustrates this.”

The judgement is available here.

Share this article