Specialist, top-rated family law advice, representation and mediation in the heart of the city of Cambridge.

Contact us for an initial chat about how we can help you.

Contact

Contact

01223 443331

Published On: 13 June 2024

Court intermediaries an expensive resource, judge insists

Court intermediaries should only be applied for if there no alternative options available, a family court judge has explained.

 

During care proceedings brought by the family’s local authority, the mother applied for the help of an intermediary in court. In the judgement of Mr Justice Williams, the children were referred to as X and Y, their mother as A and father as B.

 

Court intermediaries are independent court officials who assist vulnerable parties with communication difficulties, due to age, disability, illness, learning difficulties, mental health issues, neurodivergence, or similar factors.

 

Facilitators assess the communication difficulties of individuals they are working with and provide detailed reports on these for court officials, judges, barristers, and any other parties who may need to interact with their clients.

 

In this case, the mother’s application explained:

 

“The Respondent Mother has a diagnosis of PTSD and ADHD and requires support of an intermediary throughout proceedings. The personal and intimate nature of proceedings, as well as the client’s dual diagnoses, may impact the client’s ability to understand, focus and digest documents and information throughout the hearings, and proceedings more generally, but a specialist assessment is required to identify these issues and to ensure the Mother’s Article 6 rights are protected and she is able to give her best evidence.”

 

Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights governs the right to a fair trial.

 

In court, all parties initially agreed to the provision of an intermediary for the mother, except for the judge, who insisted that there were obstacles to the request. The mother then asked to adjourn her application, “to be restored if an evidential base for it was established”, and the Judge agreed to this.

 

The Judge went on to consider the legal framework for the appointment of intermediaries. He explained that intermediaries were a limited and expensive resource that should only be used where absolutely necessary:

 

“An intermediary can be an essential component in what the court provides to a party or witness to enable them to participate fairly in proceedings or in giving their best evidence and my own experience demonstrates their value in appropriate cases. The issue however is where is it appropriate to direct the use of an intermediary as they are not to be used as some sort of safety net or security blanket by lawyers or the courts but only where their use is necessary. Like other court funded resources (whether judicial or otherwise) they are a limited resource and a resource which comes with significant costs.”

 

 

The Judge stressed the importance of fully exploring other methods of supporting individuals with communication difficulties:

 

“A major component of the role of Legal representatives (solicitor and counsel) is to ensure their client understands the proceedings and their role in them, putting their views to the court, ensuring their client is able to give them instructions in advance of court and in court and enabling them to attend court without significant distress. Only if the court is satisfied that the usual support a legal team (adopting the use of the tools available) and other measures available to the court will not enable the party to participate fairly will it be necessary to provide for an intermediary.”

 

Therefore, he explained, the appointment of intermediaries should only be considered in cases of real need, where an individual’s right to a fair hearing in court would be jeopardised with such assistance.

 

Tricia Ashton, one of the partners here at Cambridge Family Law Practice, notes:

 

“This judgement helpfully highlights the need for moderation when considering a court intermediary. They should not be sought casually, but instead considered an expensive resource only to be considered when there are no alternative options.”

 

The judgement is available here.

Share this article