Specialist, top-rated family law advice, representation and mediation in the heart of the city of Cambridge.

Contact us for an initial chat about how we can help you.

Contact

Contact

01223 443331

Published On: 29 May 2024

Sperm donor the legal father of child, declares family court

The recently reported case of P v Q and others [2024] EWFC 85 (B) concerns a man who entered a sperm donation agreement with a same sex couple has been declared their daughter’s legal parent following the breakdown of the couple’s marriage.

The couple had been keen to become parents and had made an informal arrangement with the man, who was referred to in the legal judgment as ‘F’. Two attempts at artificial insemination, based on information gleaned from a fertility app, were unsuccessful. The spouse seeking to become pregnant, ‘P’, then secretly had sexual intercourse with F on several occasions, believing this would make pregnancy more likely to occur. Then another attempt was made at artificial insemination, and at that point, P finally became pregnant. The child, referred to as ‘X’, was born in 2017, and P and her partner ‘Q’ were named as her parents on the birth certificate.

However, by 2021 their relationship had broken down and the couple had separated. They later divorced. P then began to encourage F to spend time with X.

Meanwhile, Q applied for a child arrangements order, specifying how much time she should be able to spend with the little girl. This led to arguments between her and P over the extent to which F should be involved and the circumstances of their daughter’s conception. P believed that her daughter had been born as a result of her intercourse with F, and eventually applied for a legal declaration that F was X’s actual legal parent, not Q.

Assisted reproduction like artificial insemination is governed by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (HFEA). Part II of this legislation is based on two presumptions: that the spouse or partner of the party who becomes pregnant fully consents, and that the pregnancy did indeed occur via assisted reproduction. But if it can be shown that either presumption is in doubt, the case will fall outside the remit of the HFEA and instead be subject to the more usual assumptions of paternity under common law.

In the Family Division of the High Court, Mrs Justice Gwynneth Knowles considered P’s application. She concluded that:

“Determination of the facts will provide clarity as to X’s legal parentage which will be to her benefit throughout childhood and adulthood. I draw a distinction between that clarity about legal parentage and X’s lived reality as a child brought up by her biological mother and by Q who is also her parent, psychologically and emotionally speaking. That reality will not change for X even though the words on her birth certificate might. This lived reality is often forgotten in the focus on legal parentage which is but one aspect of a child’s identity. I thus find that determination will be of benefit to X’s identity legally speaking yet it will be unlikely to change her lived experience to date or in the future given that P states unequivocally that she wishes Q to remain involved in X’s life.”

The Judge reached the conclusion that the HFEA presumption in favour of Q should be rebutted and that F should be declared the legal parent, in spite of some uncertainties as to the circumstances:

“…I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities that P and F had sexual intercourse on several occasions prior to the third attempt at AI [artificial insemination] for which he acted as a sperm donor. The occasions on which they had sexual intercourse were within the conception window identified by the [fertility app] used by P and Q to determine when insemination might best achieve conception. P found out she was pregnant two weeks after the last occasion of AI but I am unable to find, on the balance of probabilities, whether X was conceived by AI or by NI. Q did not consent to natural intercourse between P and F but only to artificial insemination using F’s sperm.”

Mrs Justice Knowles said the case should serve as a warning to other couples who enter legally unenforceable, casual arrangements with sperm or egg donors:

“This case is a cautionary tale about the consequences for a child and for a same-sex couple of both deceit as to how that child came to be conceived and the unreliability of informal arrangements for artificial insemination. The fallout from this couple’s separation has been devastating for each of them and for their named sperm donor. In due course, the child concerned will need an age-appropriate explanation of what happened when she was conceived and why it is that she now has a different birth-certificate.”

Jeremy Ford, one of the partners here at the Cambridge Family Law Practice, said:

“This unusual but illuminating case underlines the fragility of informal fertility arrangements and the importance of solid legal advice when considering assisted reproduction.”

Share this article